Social Work Reform Survey: key findings
A follow-up survey by SASW of 90 social work practitioners and leaders across Scotland found strong support for collaborative working with health colleagues, but deep concern about the impact of current integration arrangements and proposals for greater NHS control of social work services.
When asked what future model respondents would support, only 1% responded ‘Greater integration with NHS services.’ This is a categorical rejection of the current proposals by the Scottish Government.
Almost nine in ten respondents (87.8%) work closely with health professionals in their day-to-day roles, demonstrating these views come from people with direct experience of integrated working. However, only 5.6% believe current integrated arrangements support effective social work practice.
Respondents consistently described a widening gap between a rights-based social work model and systems increasingly shaped by hospital pressures, delayed discharge targets and resource constraints. Read the full report findings below.
The issue is not collaborative working
The survey does not suggest opposition to partnership working. Instead, respondents raised concerns that social work is increasingly being treated as a subordinate rather than equal partner within integrated arrangements.
Key findings include:
- 65.6% disagree that social work is treated as an equal partner in decision-making.
- 64.4% report that colleagues from other professions lack a good understanding of the social work role.
- Only 20.0% agree they have sufficient time for direct work with people and communities.
Many respondents described a culture in which hospital performance pressures increasingly shape priorities, often at the expense of prevention, community support and rights-based practice.
Strong opposition to greater NHS control
The clearest finding in the survey relates to proposals that would move social work closer to NHS control.
Respondents overwhelmingly believe greater NHS control would weaken social work's ability to deliver effective support:
- 93.3% say it would weaken social work's influence in decision-making.
- 92.2% say it would weaken the professional identity of social work.
- 90.0% say it would weaken professional autonomy and judgement.
- 81.1% believe it would weaken outcomes for people and communities.
- 80.0% believe it would weaken prevention and early intervention.
These findings suggest concerns extend well beyond organisational structures. Respondents see social work's independence as essential to safeguarding rights, promoting wellbeing, advocating for vulnerable people and supporting communities.
Significant support for a return to local authority accountability
Perhaps the most striking governance finding is the level of support for restoring clearer local authority accountability and control for social work services.
A return to clearer local authority accountability and control was the single most popular future model, selected by 48.9% of respondents and attracting almost twice the support of retaining the current HSCP model with improvements (26.7%).
A further 31.1% of respondents said current integrated arrangements should be fundamentally redesigned.
Taken together, these findings point to a significant appetite for reform and a clear desire for stronger local accountability, clearer governance arrangements and greater social work influence over decisions affecting the people and communities it support.
What is really at stake?
A consistent message throughout the survey was that this debate is not primarily about protecting a profession or resisting change.
Respondents repeatedly linked social work's independence, leadership and professional autonomy to its ability to improve lives, uphold rights and deliver effective support.
The survey suggests that, in the eyes of practitioners, the fundamental question is not who controls services, but whether future reforms will strengthen or weaken the quality of support, rights-based practice, independence and outcomes experienced by the people and communities social work exists to serve.